Category 1: Class of Hydroponics
Category 2: Nutrient Derivations
Category 3: Types of Hydroponic Systems: Open/Closed
- High Density Vertical (HDV)
- Nutrient Film Technique (NFT)
- Deep Water Culture (DWC)
- Ebb and Flow
There is some controversy over the way to classify hydroponic systems. The purpose of this article is to explain the three different ways hydroponic systems are categorized. Different systems can be organized into three separate categories. The categories are useful because they describe different aspects of each system. Let’s take a look.
The first of the categories is “Class of Hydroponics”, which describes the way the roots are supported in the system. There are 3 classes of systems, Agroponics, Aeroponics, & Aquaponics.
- Agroponics: in this class, roots are supported in a solid, inert, aggregate media such as coconut coir, perlite, or expanded clay pellets.
- Aeroponics: in this class, the roots are suspended in a closed, dark, chamber where nutrient solution is constantly sprayed onto them.
- Aquaponics: in this class, the roots are immersed in an aerated nutrient-rich solution. The term “Aquaponics” tends to be associated with fish and plant production in the same system, but this is a misconception. Aqua just means “water,” so the roots are suspended in water. We’ll talk more about that in the next section.
The second category is called “Nutrient Derivations”, which describes the source of the nutrient solution for a hydroponic system. There are 3 types of nutrient derivations, Hydroponic, Bioponic & Aquaculture. Take note that the term Hydroponic is used to describe all systems in which a nutrient solution, regardless of its derivation, is dissolved in water.
- Hydroponic is also used to describe the nutrient derivation, it is referring to a nutrient solution made from concentrated minerals, which is the classic form of hydroponic nutrients.
- Bioponic is the second form and is derived from biologically decomposed organic matter, such as compost teas and fish emulations. This form excludes any systems with live fish.
- Aquaculture, which describes fish or shellfish farming and refers to the breeding, rearing, and harvesting of aquatic plants and animals in all types of aquatic environments including ponds, rivers, lakes, and the ocean.
The third category is called “Types of Hydroponic Systems”, and describes the way nutrient solution is delivered to the roots. Within this category, there are two main types of hydroponic systems, Open and Closed. In Open Systems, the nutrient solution is delivered to the roots, and then released into a garden bed or down a drain. The nutrient solution in Closed Systems is delivered to the roots, and then returned to a reservoir or holding tank for reuse within the system. These types of systems are recirculating, and nutrients are added to the reservoir to replace nutrients that roots take up. Usually, systems with no media such as Aeroponics and Aquaponics systems are Closed Systems. Systems with media, or Agroponics, can be either open or closed. There are many types of hydroponic systems, and each type can be either open or closed depending on how it’s set up. Here are a few examples:
- High Density Vertical (HDV): This describes the vertical arrangement of stackable, high-density plastic pots, such as EzGro quad pots. Nutrients are usually delivered through a drip tube or PVC pipe into a distribution pot, where roots absorb nutrient solution, and then it trickles down to the pot below, and so on.
- Vertical: This describes the vertical arrangement of the plant itself, when fruiting plants are supported with strings and clips or a trellis. This method is typically used for tomatoes and cucumbers.
- Nutrient Film Technique (NFT): Roots are suspended in a gutter-like channel, through which nutrient solution constantly passes.
- Deep Water Culture (DWC): Plants float on top of a nutrient-rich solution, usually supported by a sheet of polystyrene. This is also known as a raft
- Ebb and Flow: This is typically a media based system. The grow bed is flooded with nutrient solution for a set amount of time several times per day, then it is drained.
- Drip: This is typically a media based system. Nutrients are delivered to the roots through a drip stake or PVC pipe several times throughout the day. A timer is usually used to regulate the nutrient delivery.
In order to organize these classes even further, let’s look at a few examples. Let’s say we have Dutch buckets filled with expanded clay pellets, and the concentrated mineral nutrient solution is delivered through drip stakes. Once the roots take up the nutrition they need-, the nutrient solution drains into a garden bed. This is Agroponics, because of the clay media and Hydroponics because of the nutrient derivation. The specific description of this system is an “open Agroponic drip system using Hydroponics.”
Let’s say we have a High Density Vertical (HDV) system with coconut coir inside the pots. This system recirculates compost tea as its fertilizer. This can be described as both Agroponics, because of the coconut coir media and Bioponics, because the nutrient solution is derived from decomposed organic matter. This example is called a “closed Agroponic drip system using Bioponics.”
Let’s look at one more example. This system has a fish tank with goldfish, and a polystyrene raft with plants set into it floating on top of the tank. This can be described as Aquaponics, because the plant roots are suspended directly in the nutrient solution, as well as Aquaculture, because fish are providing the nutrients for the plants. This example is called a “closed Aquaponic deep water culture system using aquaculture.”
Keep in mind these are just examples, and are not necessarily the best way to set up a system for optimum productivity. We will publish more articles in the coming weeks on every system type, how they excel, and where they can be improved.
The purpose of all these classifications is to describe every aspect of a specific hydroponic system. When looking at a system, it is important to understand how the roots are supported, how the nutrient solution is derived, and how it is delivered to the roots. This foundation of hydroponics is important to understand existing systems, and to be more precise while building new systems.
This MailChimp shortcode is now deprecated. Please insert the new shortcode to display this form.
- BrightFarm Systems was commissioned to design and install a demonstration scale, sustainable urban greenhouse for a new Whole Foods Market store in Millburn, New Jersey. Sustainable Agriculture and Wise Environmental Practices are two core values of Whole Foods Market. They are also significant supporters of local farmers in the Northeast region and beyond. The demonstration scale greenhouse system was designed…
- There are two main types of hydroponic systems - closed hydroponic systems and open hydroponic systems. Hydroponic systems that do not involve growing media are usually closed systems, while hydroponic systems that involve growing media (container plants), may be closed or open systems. Closed Hydroponic Systems Closed hydroponic systems the same nutrient solution is recirculated and the nutrient concentrations are monitored and adjusted accordingly. Keeping the…
- Welcome back! Let’s keep discussing the different categories of hydroponics. If you haven’t read our Foundation of Hydroponics article, check it out first, then meet back here. Just to recap, the first category that is used to classify hydroponic systems is called the Class of Hydroponics, and it describes how plant roots are supported in a system. We already talked…
- Fertilizer vs. Hydroponic Nutrients In order to begin a discussion on hydroponic nutrients, it’s important to first distinguish the difference between the terms fertilizer and hydroponic nutrient. Fertilizer is intended to feed the microorganisms in the soil, such as beneficial bacteria and fungi. All of the living components in the soil must be protected, so fertilizer is lower in concentration…